Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Blogs | Writers | My Orble | Login

Book Club - by Suhaili

Book Club - October 2008

The Youngest Templar

October 10th 2008 05:14


This is a new kids-aimed fantasy/historical novel and from what I understand it is the first volume in what will probably be a trilogy if not a series of novels (novellas). I went into this book not really expecting anything, it was sent to me from over the seas (okay, from America) and I found it to be a rollicking and pleasant read.


It is the middle ages (more specifically, the dark ages). Tristan is a young orphan of mysterious origins who is co-opted into the order of the Knights Templar and finds himself flung headfirst into the Crusades. Sooner or later he and his kindly master find themselves in a Saracen-enforced seige (soon to be slaughter) and Tristan is entrusted with a valuable Templar artifact (okay, it's the Holy Grail) and given instructions to take it to safety. Boundless adventure ensues!

Like I said earlier, this is a pleasant read. There's nothing pretentious or forced about it, it's an historical adventure aimed at a young audience but fit to read for anyone who likes this sort of thing. I tend to like this sort of thing. It's peppered with lots of cool medieval details, and it could probably be called semi-educational in respect to how realistic it reads (but not in a dry, non-kid friendly way). The Crusades aren't the most fun-packed of historical events and the author does well not to sugarcoat or romantacize it. The writing style is effective, and the characterisations are memorable and seemingly effortless - which is no mean feat when you've only got 240 pages and a fairly large font to work with.


There were two little things that kind of threw me off a bit. The first, and more major one, was the inclusion of a cast of supporting characters that seem to have come straight from the story of Robin Hood. I was left scratching my head a bit as to the relevance of this... it's as if the author felt his story wasn't strong enough on it's own so he went and chucked in some medieval 'celebrities' to keep the kids entertained. I want to say that it wasn't necessary but this is the first book in a series so I'll reserve judgement in case the real relevance of this becomes more apparent in later volumes. The second quibble, and this is a more minor one (and the blame may fall on the publishing company rather than the author), is the decision to use American spellings rather than English. Normally I wouldn't care but it just feels wrong given the subject matter, setting, and the fact that the whole thing is concerned with English events and English history. It's a first-hand account told from the point of a view of an English peasant boy... for him to adopt American spelling when America hasn't even come into existence yet is just jarring. It hardly effected my enjoyment of the book but this is my blog and I'll get on my soapbox as much as I like, so nyah.

I hate to start all my final paragraphs with 'anyway' but anyway, this is a great action-packed fast-paced novel and I'd recommend it to any parents looking to get their boys interested in reading. The parents might even like to read it too.
91
Vote
   


Admit One

October 3rd 2008 06:25


I don't think I really ever reviewed a memoir before. At least, not one written by someone who wasn't so famous my nuts would shrink upon meeting them (okay, shrink more). This rather slight and slender tome is the memoir of up-and-coming British actor Emmett James. I was approached via email by someone representing the book who had no doubt stumbled across this much esteemed blog (haw haw haw) and wanted to know if I was interested in reading this book. Taking it to be some kind of analysis of films or a fictional novel heavily influenced by film-geekdom I replied - yes, of course I am interested, please send it along and I will read and review.

I'll cut to the chase for those involved with the book's writing and publication (in the off-chance case they are reading this review); I didn't hate this book, but it did leave me scratching my head a little.

Basically, the book is divided up into short chapters - each one named after and loosely connected to one of the author's favourite films. Each chapter deals with a chapter in the author's life, the earlier ones dealing with his croydon-based childhood and the later ones dealing with his forays into the world of film-acting. It's a fairly brief book, probably owing to the fact that the author is relatively young and is yet to become a household name.

It starts in quite a promising fashion, with suitable payouts levelled at Steven Segal and a cheeky and well-educated wit carrying along the prose, but I have to say I was a little disappointed to find that the connection between each chapter's story and the films they were named after became very tenuous at best, and I really was expecting less in the way of an actual memoir and more in the way of film analysis. I can't dwell on that too much because it was pretty much just my expectation - I don't know where it came from, so: my bad.

There are several amusing anecdotes throughout the book, the most amusing probably being the thinly veiled story about the author's attempt to audition for the part of Robin in Batman Forever. I couldn't help but laugh at how little effort he went to in disguising Joel Schumacher's identity. But what ended up confusing me was that just when the story started heading somewhere (I assumed it was building up to the author's big breakthrough role or something else that warranted the hyperbole written in the 'about the author' section) the book just ended. Is that it? Is the highlight of this guy's career a bit part in Titanic? Maybe the book is marketed oddly or something, I could understand it if the book was packaged as 'how I tried to break into Hollywood and almost made it' or the 'trials and the tribulations of an up-and-comer' but during the course of reading the book I just felt like it was selling Emmett James to me as a big star recounting his early days. I know everyone's life is of equal value (in theory) but if I was to write a memoir of my childhood and how I came to work in a bookstore at the grand old age of 28 I can guarantee there would be more than a few readers prefacing their reviews with a big 'so what?'

Sorry, it was an entertaining read and I always feel bad about not giving a great review when someone goes to the effort of sending a book all the way from America or England to my home in suburban Australia, but I felt a little disappointed when I finished reading this. I think it would've been much more effective if it had been fictionalised to an extent, making the book a literary adventure closely based on the author's experiences or something. But hey, maybe I'm missing the point.
79
Vote
   


More Posts
1 Posts
1 Posts
1 Posts
275 Posts dating from April 2006
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:
Moderated by Suhaili
Copyright © 2006 2007 2008 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]