Does My Head Look Big In This?
February 10th 2008 09:10
A while ago I wrote an article about Randa Abdel-Fattah, click here to see what I had to say and how much I've back-peddled with this review. It's not that I disagree with my optimistic appraisal of Abdel-Fattah or her inspiring status as a potential role-model for young Australians, but what I am at odds with is how excited I sound at the end of said article in regards to reading her debut novel, Does My Head Look Big in This?. I was wrong to be excited. The book sounded good, and Abdel-Fattah's skills as a public speaker (no doubt honed by her dayjob as a lawyer) helped sell the book to me. In light of now having read the actual thing I have to admit that the book isn't actually all that good. Which is a shame, especially as so many people recommended it to me.
The basic premise of Does My Head Look Big in This? seems to be to do Looking for Alibrandi with Muslim-Australians instead of Italian-Australians. The main character, Amal, is a 16 year old muslim girl at a predominantly white-bread anglo-Australian private school. One morning she wakes up and decides that it's time to wear the hijab, the scarf that muslim women wear to cover their hair as part of their faith, and the book follows the consequences of this amongst her friends, family and peers at school.
There are various subplots that pertain to what it means to adhere to the islamic faith within Australian society and the book deals with themes of cultural and social identity and all that jazz. Abdel-Fattah works to dispel many myths about Australian muslims and islam in general, and she writes with a breezy, easygoing style in the hope of making it palatable to the average teen reader. The book has won a lot of praise for it's educational qualities and politcal correctness, and I think a few schools have picked it up as a classroom English text. It was roughly 30 pages into the book when I first had to suppress the urge to spew.
I'm sorry, and I understand the need to combat the common mainstream perceptions of muslim-Australian society, but Does My Head Look Big in This? takes it all too far - offering an embarrassingly politically-correct, squeaky-clean story with a heroine crafted far too self-consciously to the author's designs to educate the assumed bigoted masses of white Australia. I fear she may have been preaching to the converted - those who need educating the most are those who wouldn't touch this book with a 3 metre barge pole, and those who willingly pick up a book with a quirky rom-com style muslim girl on the front probably aren't all that prejudiced to begin with either. Amal comes across as too infallible and overly precocious rather than the headstrong smart-arse she describes herself as. The continuous rallying against the misconceptions of those around her get very tiring to read and after a while it feels like a bad fish-out-of-water sitcom or disney film where the put-upon protagonist teaches her co-stars (in this case mainly made up of up-tight anglos and anglo-wannabe muslims) how to live life and love it.
Maybe my own atheist leanings made it impossible for me to be less than heavily-subjective as this is, after all, a book about remaining faithful to one's religion. As a result I found all the hoo-haring hypocrisy about Amal liking some guy to be terribly overdone and overwrought, and at the end of the day I just found it to be as alienating to me as all the anti-muslim attitudes probably are to the author. I really wanted to like this book but every page of the way I found it a struggle and full of too many subplots with too little substance, and when I reached the last few pages I wasn't convinced that anything of any consequence had really happened since the novel's beginning. In light of this, a more apt title for this book would probably be Muslims are OK, as this is pretty much all the book has to say. Who knows, maybe I just can't read predominantly-girly teen-fiction... there's bound to be at least one whole genre of writing I don't like, and maybe I just found it. That doesn't really excuse my misgivings about this book though, but it should at least dissuade me from reading any other books like it in the future!
| 142 |
| Vote |
Comment by Anonymous
it is about a girl that wants to wear a hijab and is scared because she has to deal with the bad stuff her friends are going to say to her!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11
From
Anonimus
Comment by Anonymous
it is one of the best ever.
well now i have to go and read this book.
hope everyone in theworld becomes muslim
Fr: A KID
Comment by Shan Jayaweera
Music Videos
Video Toes
Watching YouTube
Cricket Nut
Gold versus Blood
Music Videos Forum
This book looks really great and a wonderful review to go with it
when you have a moment please check out my blogs
watchingyoutube.com
and
videotoes.com
letme know what you think
Thanks
Comment by Luke
Old Movies
Cane Toad Warrior
Comment by Anonymous
I think Im going to agree with them that the book is pretty darn good.
Comment by Luke
Old Movies
Cane Toad Warrior
first of all, thank you for your indepth commentary on the review. i genuinely appreciate it, it makes a nice change from some of the ridiculous and nonsensical comments i often get on here.
i admit that my atheist leanings are probably responsible (at least in some part) for my opinion. i think i owed that as some kind of possible explanation in my efforts to be as objective as possible. believe it or not, i don't have anything against muslims, and i did feel a bit uncomfortable writing what i wrote as i was afraid it could be interpreted as some kind of bigotry or discrimination on my part BUT please believe me, that this is not my intention and that i am NOT a discriminatory person (see my previous article on Randa Abdel-Fattah for proof of this).
I read this book hoping and wanting to like it - i was disappointed that i didn't, and to not reflect this in my review would be dishonest on my part. i tried to analyze why i didn't like this book, and the above review is the end result. I don't accept that my own personal beliefs are the ONLY reasons why I disliked it, but I do accept that these beliefs probably made it easier for me to pick up on the preachiness that is implicit throughout the novel.
thanks for stopping by, and like you said - everyone is entitled to their opinion, i'd be silly not to realise that.
Comment by Anonymous
Comment by Luke
Old Movies
Cane Toad Warrior
Comment by Anonymous
i'm an australian teenage girl and i first read it a few years back and really enjoyed it. it helped me learn about muslim culture which i had known practically nothing about.
so to you, luke, who said she was preaching to the already converted; that's not true. i was converted because of this book. it helped me understand the culture and ways of muslim people which was really good because there are a few muslim girls at my school and it was great to be able to look at them and understand their beliefs.
i also don't belong to any religion.
thanks
Comment by Anonymous
Comment by i am a GOONA
probli bcuz i ddnt read da book
lmao
...serioulslii i ddnt
anyways plannin 2 read dis book cuz ma mates rate it, but dnt have tym cuz of ma gcse nd craap
but cn i read dis book online...
..????
pls sen link if i cn
i will be 4eva gratefull
=)
Comment by Luke
Old Movies
Cane Toad Warrior
heres a lnk
ww.dzmyhdlookbginths.com
nt sur abt the spelln? hope it helpz
Comment by angelis a goona
fanks dude
...erm if u were talkin bout my spellin..I NO I NO its craap
but...BUT i cn spell...its jst da msn and txt message language its soo easy now..( i used 2 fynd it sooo hard)
I LEARN =D
fank u...again =)
Comment by angelis a goona
u MEANII Your text goes here !!!!
Comment by angelis a goona
=P
u MEANII !!!!
Comment by Anonymous
Comment by Anonymous
Comment by Anonymous
and i would recommend it x
Someone should make it into a film that would be gdxx
Comment by Anonymous
it's not the best book I've read nor the worse.
so. there really is no need to even be discussing it so "violently".
I'm only here 'cuz I've gotta do it for my assignment.
get over it people.
Comment by Anonymous
Comment by Anonymous
I read the book for my english assingment and I agree with you, it wasn't all that good. Maybe i just didn't like it because im a teenage guy and what teenage guy wants to read about a silly girl who cares what people think about her. I think most the people in this forum who have read the book have been sucked in by Author and can't see past the silencing and marginalization she's used through out the book. Thats just my opinoin anyway.
Comment by katey
when i read this book i was sucked in i really enjoyed it it was awesome i had to also do it for an english assignment, when i saw it i thought yuk do i have to read this book buh wen i read the first couple of pages i was sucked in its a great book from a great author.